[opendmarc-users] DMARC no sign

[test at infinitynet.ro]

Hello Dominic, 

If i use Roundcube to send email everything its fine. 

--
Thanks,
Gabriel 

On 2018-08-23 10:42, Dominic Raferd wrote: 

> On Thu, 23 Aug 2018 at 07:02, test <test at infinitynet.ro> wrote: 
> 
>> Hello Benny,
>> 
>> I have this:
>> 
>> Aug 23 01:05:28 mail opendmarc[29753]: E9816301A73 ignoring Authentication-Results at 6 from infinitynet.ro/6436730197E [1]
>> Aug 23 01:05:28 mail opendmarc[29753]: E9816301A73: SPF(mailfrom): test at infinitynet.ro pass
>> Aug 23 01:05:28 mail opendmarc[29753]: E9816301A73: infinitynet.ro [2] pass
>> 
>> job E9816301A73
>> reporter mail.infinitynet.ro [3]
>> received 1534975528
>> ipaddr 127.0.0.1
>> from infinitynet.ro [2]
>> mfrom infinitynet.ro [2]
>> spf 0
>> pdomain infinitynet.ro [2]
>> policy 15
>> rua mailto:hrkgeyto at ag.dmarcian-eu.com
>> pct 100
>> adkim 114
>> aspf 114
>> p 113
>> sp 0
>> align_dkim 5
>> align_spf 4
>> action 2
>> 
>> VS
>> 
>> Aug 23 01:06:39 mail opendmarc[29753]: 504E430197E: SPF(mailfrom): test at infinitynet.ro fail
>> Aug 23 01:06:39 mail opendmarc[29753]: 504E430197E: infinitynet.ro [2] fail
>> 
>> job 504E430197E
>> reporter mail.infinitynet.ro [3]
>> received 1534975599
>> ipaddr 77.81.71.71
>> from infinitynet.ro [2]
>> mfrom infinitynet.ro [2]
>> spf 7
>> pdomain infinitynet.ro [2]
>> policy 17
>> rua mailto:hrkgeyto at ag.dmarcian-eu.com
>> pct 100
>> adkim 114
>> aspf 114
>> p 113
>> sp 0
>> align_dkim 5
>> align_spf 5
>> action 2
> 
> OP: your domain spf setting is: 
> "v=spf1 a mx a:mail.infinitynet.ro [3] a:infinitynet.ro [2] ip4:188.208.128.110 ip4:85.204.166.226 -all" 
> 
> And your DMARC setting is: p=quarantine 
> 
> Mailservers which enforce SPF strictly will block any emails from yourself that are relayed through another server such as mailing list (reason: '-all'). Personally I think blocking based only on SPF is a bad idea, but you can't control what others do. 
> 
> Moreover, emails that you send through some mailing lists (including, ironically, this one) will fail DMARC (reason: SPF fails *and* DKIM alignment fails) and because you have 'p=quarantine' they will end up in recipients' spam folders. 
> 
> My advice is to use a different domain when posting to mailing lists, including this one i.e. one that doesn't has no DMARC policy or else p=none, and either has no SPF policy or does not use '-all'. 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> opendmarc-users mailing list
> opendmarc-users at trusteddomain.org
> http://www.trusteddomain.org/mailman/listinfo/opendmarc-users [4]

 

Links:
------
[1] http://infinitynet.ro/6436730197E
[2] http://infinitynet.ro
[3] http://mail.infinitynet.ro
[4] http://www.trusteddomain.org/mailman/listinfo/opendmarc-users
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.trusteddomain.org/pipermail/opendmarc-users/attachments/20180823/a13573fe/attachment.htm>