[opendmarc-users] Is there a "buest-guess DMARC" in opendmarc?

[Simon]

Hi Juri,

Am 07.05.2017 um 14:48 schrieb Juri Haberland:
> On 07.05.2017 14:07, Sim wrote:
>
>> Was this discussed earlier?: Can OpenDMARC indicate if DMARC
>> authentication result would have been a "pass" if a DMARC record was
>> found? This would save downstream filters (i.e. list membership based on
>> RFC5322.From) from re-implementing an alignment check.
>>
>> Currently, with (SPF or DKIM)=pass and in_alignment with the
>> RFC5322.From the DMARC result is 'none'. But isn't "would have been a
>> pass" different than 'none'?
> Well, "none" means no DMARC RR found, "pass" means DMARC RR present and
> mail passed - or am I missing something?
>
I mean another result for: "DMARC-like" domain authentication passed but
(unfortunately) no DMARC record found.

Like so (with XXXX replaced to something other than 'none'):

Authentication-Results: mail.simonliebold.de; dmarc=XXXX (p=none dis=none) header.from=trusteddomain.org
Authentication-Results: mail.simonliebold.de; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=trusteddomain.org
Authentication-Results: mail.simonliebold.de; dkim=pass


Simon